**EDIT: Fixed a few minutes after posting, solution for anyone else unhinged enough to run FMOD within a WM setup. The issue still happens, but this is what a guard would look like in my case. Not sure if this is something that’d show up on other compositors under their own multi monitor / XWayland handling.
Within a .lua file read by hyprland):
local FMOD_CLASSES = { ["fmodstudio"] = true, ["fmod-studio"] = true }
-- force move popups (bare window titles within FMOD) whose position is detected
-- outside of the monitor we clicked on to snap to cursor, to fix positioning bug
-- where some right-hand side popups would display on an adjacent monitor due to
-- some kind of transform / compositor oddity.
hl.on("window.open", function(w)
if not w or not FMOD_CLASSES[w.class] then
return
end
if w.title ~= w.class or not w.floating then
return
end
local mon = hl.get_monitor_at_cursor()
local cur = hl.get_cursor_pos()
if not mon or not cur then
return
end
local box = helpers.monitorLogicalBox(mon)
local px, py = w.at.x, w.at.y
local pw, ph = w.size.x, w.size.y
if px >= box.x and px + pw <= box.right and py >= box.y and py + ph <= box.bottom then
return
end
local nx = (cur.x + pw <= box.right) and cur.x or (cur.x - pw)
local ny = (cur.y + ph <= box.bottom) and cur.y or (cur.y - ph)
hl.dispatch(hl.dsp.window.move({
x = nx,
y = ny,
relative = false,
window = "address:" .. w.address,
}))
end)
Hello folks! FMOD 2.2.34 user.
Like many of us, I’ve been exploring Linux for the first time this year. And first off, I just wanted to say how thrilled I am that you all have packaged a native Linux build, it was a delight to see when I first started setting things up a few months ago.
I’m running under Hyprland as a compositor, so Wayland only with Xwayland translation for FMOD’s GUI. Setting the scale factor to 1.5 makes everything work just about perfectly.
One weird bug: if I have multiple monitors running (I usually do), right-clicking an element and spawning a pop-up right-click menu from within the Overview dock on the right hand edge of the event editor (e.g. to choose “Replace with parameter”) while the FMOD client is positioned within the right half of the screen (fullscreen also counts), will cause the popup to spawn on the left monitor instead, free floating in space. This does not happen when:
- I’m using only a single monitor
- The FMOD window containing the element I’m right-clicking (let’s just say, an event editor) is on the left half-ish of the screen
- On most right-click popups. Just the ones that would appear under the cursor at the right edge of the screen
I chalked this up to a Wayland window positioning quirk or translation issue with the compositor’s handling of Xwayland, but have drilled into it a bunch (caveat, with AI, optimistically trying many, many angles) and can’t resolve it. Changing xwayland scaling behavior doesn’t seem to make a difference. Monitor enumeration order and compositor scaling translation were both ruled out as factors, too: the popup’s raw X11 position matches what should be given the x2 scaling translation logic in place for my whole monitor (my eyes aren’t great anymore, need it zoomed a bit). And anyways, it’s ONLY this specific type of popup! Maddening.
AI’s best working theory is that this could be a bug in the Qt widget code you’re using. I’ve just tried the latest FMOD 2.3.14 build, and the same thing happens, so I don’t think it’s that.
I realize this is a tiny little rabbit hole, but if you’re interested in smoothing edge cases for folks exploring window managers / Wayland generally, let me know and I’d be happy to share my experiences so far, I’m collecting data points.
Attached are two screenshots showing the scenario where the popup lands outside my monitor, and one where it works normally. The difference seems to be in where the baseline FMOD window is positioned so I do suspect it’s something having to do with overflow position calculation.
Thanks again!!
